Average rating: (2 reviews)

The Grim Company

In:

36 votes
+28
|
-8


Appears on 6 lists in total.
Appears on 4 master lists.
Appears on 2 voting lists.
Appears on 0 non-voting lists.
14
...

MORE
  • Author: Luke Scull
  • Publish Date: 2014-03-04
  • People Who Like The Grim Company Also Like...


    The Grim Company Ranks On The Following Lists:


    Best Anti-Hero Fantasy(Ranked 18 out of 28)

    The crowd-ranked version of BestFantasyBooks.com's Best Anti-Hero Fantasy Books list.This list gives some of the top fantasy reads that feature strong anti-hero types as the protagonist.Vote on the bo...

    MORE

    Best Fantasy Books Since 2010(Ranked 21 out of 57)

    This is the crowd-ranked version of The Top 25 Best Fantasy Books Since 2010 that's on the main site. The idea behind this list is to give readers a list of the best of the best of recently published...

    MORE

    Best Grimdark Fantasy Books(Ranked 9 out of 50)

    There's a new type of fantasy book that's all the rage now: grimdark. Depressing worlds, gritty settings, troubled morally ambiguous heroes. These elements have thoroughly pervaded the fantasy genre t...

    MORE

    Best Fantasy Audiobooks(Ranked 59 out of 62)

    Audiobooks are a big thing now. Most books are released into two formats: kindle and audiobook. In the hands (or shall we say, voice) of a talented narrator, a good book can become an outstanding boo...

    MORE

    Best Gritty Fantasy Books(Ranked 13 out of 25)

    The crowd ranked version of our 'Best Gritty Fantasy Books' list on the main site. This list is ranked by public votes and provides an alternative to the main site's curated list ranking.

    Reviews/Comments On The Grim Company


    3 out of 3 people found this review helpful
    RE:
    By: Anonymous
    2015-05-19 06:23:15

    You must have a better tolerance for bad writing that I do to rank this so highly. By the time I got to page 22 I was so overwelmed by cliche'd turns of phrase and 'talking at the reader' loredumps that I had to put it down. Pushing on the page 45 and it hadn't improved. Fantasy isn't the height of good writing but when it stands out so much within a few pages its hard to press on.

    I've seen a lot of people saying the plot is cliche'd but really that doesn't matter if its well written, which this isn't.

    This book is great if you want cliche'd phrases, completly implausable sounding dialogue full of video game style exposition, an overdose of adjectives and place names that sound like they've come directly from a 10 year old's treasure map.

    Was this review helpful to you?
    0 out of 0 people found this review helpful
    RE:
    By: Anonymous
    2016-04-03 05:39:12

    Could not get more than a couple chapters into this garbage. The writer seems to have written characters to be shallow parodies of themselves.

    Was this review helpful to you?
    0 out of 0 people found this review helpful
    RE:
    By: Anonymous
    2016-12-28 09:01:22

    It is just bad writing all around. I do not understand comparison with Abercrombie - ok, it is supposedly gritty and all, but really, as a writer Luke Scull is mediocre at best.

    Was this review helpful to you?
    0 out of 0 people found this review helpful
    RE:
    By: Anonymous
    2017-04-29 02:37:17

    Luke Scull's grim company is similar to when you take someone else's essay changes a couple words and add a few sentences and then pass it off as your own.
    The main characters seems to be pastiches from Abercrombie and GRR Martin's books.
    The plot is predicable for the first two books. The author does try to spice things up in the third book but fails spectacularly.
    The Grim Company was a never a great series but it was still enjoyable until the third book came out. Although the first two books are featured derivative characters and predicable plots they were enjoyable to me. But the third book in the trilogy is the final nail in the coffin. Simply put Luke messed up the entire plot in dead man's steel.

    1.The existing threat which the author built up in the previous books to be credible and menacing is abruptly sbsolved.
    2.A whole cast of enemies with their background lore is suddenly introduced in the beginning of the last book.
    3.The protagonist's arc with the gods, which the author invested many chapters to build up,does not really go anywhere.

    Luke should have kept the plot simple he just does not have the talent to pull off a more grandiose plot.

    Was this review helpful to you?





    How Would You Rate The Grim Company? (leave blank if you just want to comment on the book and not review it):